Torn between open shelves and cabinets? Discover real DIY tips from my kitchen makeover, including pros, cons, mistakes, and styling tricks.
I Tried Both—Here’s What I Learned When I Changed My Kitchen Myself
When I first decided to refresh my kitchen, I wasn’t aiming for a full renovation. I just wanted something simple that could change the vibe without wrecking my budget. The first thing that caught my eye? All those Pinterest-worthy kitchens with open shelves instead of traditional cabinets. They looked light and stylish, and everything was within reach. But I kept wondering—is this actually practical, or just pretty in pictures?
So I tested it myself. I removed two cabinet doors and installed wooden shelves in their place. That’s when the real comparison began—open shelving vs. closed cabinets, side by side.
1. Visual Impact: Lightness vs Order 
Open shelves instantly made the kitchen feel lighter, especially above the sink. The wall became visible, light bounced off the tiles, and the space felt bigger.
Closed cabinets gave a sense of order. Everything was hidden; there was no visual clutter. How to Install a DIY Backsplash That Transforms Your Kitchen
2. Accessibility: Open Shelves Win 
I’m someone who likes things within reach. Open shelves made it super easy to grab mugs, spices, and everyday dishes. No doors to open, no extra steps.
But when I started placing less-used items on the shelves, they piled up and looked messy. Best Paint Brushes and Rollers for Beginners
3. Cleaning: Cabinets Take the Lead 
Open shelves collect dust and grease fast—especially near the stove. I had to wipe them weekly and wash the items regularly.
Closed cabinets protect everything inside. Less cleaning, more peace of mind.
4. Storage Capacity: Cabinets Win
Cabinets offer deeper, more concealed storage. Open shelves are limited—not ideal for bulky or unattractive items. 
I tried placing my blender and storage containers on the shelves, but they looked out of place.
5. Style & Personality: Shelves Win Big 
Open shelves let me express my style. I added spice jars, cookbooks, and small plants. Everyone who walked in commented on how cozy and personal it felt.
Cabinets hide all that—but they do keep things neat and uniform.
How to Read a Tape Measure Accurately
6. Installation: Shelves Are Easier 
I installed the shelves myself—just screws and a drill. Cabinets require more skill and often a professional.
If you want a quick, beginner-friendly upgrade, shelves are the way to go
Mistakes I Made (So You Don’t Have To)
- Installed weak shelves — they collapsed after a week
- Placed heavy items on unsupported brackets
- Didn’t measure the space properly
- Chose shelf colors that clashed with the rest of the kitchen
- Overloaded the shelves — looked messy and chaotic Installing a DIY Mirror and Lighting Combo
Tips That Actually Helped
- Keep shelf styling minimal and intentional
- Mix open shelves with closed cabinets for balance
- Choose shelf materials and colors that match your kitchen
- Review shelf contents monthly and declutter
- Store fragile items in cabinets if you have kids
My Final Verdict
I didn’t ditch cabinets completely, and I didn’t go all-in on shelves either. What worked best was a mix: open shelves for daily items and personality, and cabinets for storage and protection.
My kitchen feels lighter, more functional, and more “me.” And every time I walk in, I feel proud of the change I made with my own hands.
